Candy Pirates are Stickybeard's sometimes-loyal pirate crew. They are another form of Shopkeepers. If players choose Edd as their guide, they will receive missions that reward parts to candy pirate outfits. Candy Pirates' names are combinations of candy-themed terms, such as Captain Meltaway, Sugarnose, Jordan Almond, and Licorice Lips. They can often be found around sea coasts, such as Orchid Bay, Bravo Beach, the Monkey Foothills, and on the beaches of Candied Island, Destiny Islands, Prankster's Island, and Wave Island, though they also are found on Sweet Street, on the decks of the Sweet Revenge and in the Pirates' Village at Candy Cove. For some reason, a few crewmates are located in the isolated canyon of Devil's Bluff.
- Leader - Stickybeard